YouTube Shorts vs Long-Form Videos: Which One Drives More Growth?
Not sure whether to focus on YouTube Shorts or long-form videos? Learn which format is better for growth, engagement, and monetization on YouTube.

YouTube Shorts vs Long-Form Videos: Which One Drives More Growth?
If you’re serious about growing a YouTube channel in 2024 and beyond, you’ve likely asked yourself:
“Should I focus on Shorts or stick with long-form videos?”
The answer? Both can drive growth — but in very different ways.
In this post, we’ll break down:
-
The core differences between Shorts and long videos
-
Which drives faster subscriber growth
-
How each impacts your watch time, revenue, and visibility
-
And most importantly, how to use both formats strategically
🧠 The Key Differences: Shorts vs Long-Form Content
Feature | YouTube Shorts | Long-Form Videos |
---|---|---|
Length | ≤ 60 seconds | 8–15 minutes (typically) |
Placement | Shorts Feed + Search + Home | Search + Suggested + Subscriptions |
Discoverability | Viral-oriented (wide audience) | Targeted, SEO-driven |
Monetization | Lower RPM (ad rev is limited) | Higher RPM (ads, mid-rolls, etc.) |
Watch Time | Doesn’t count toward 4,000-hour mark | Counts toward monetization goal |
Sub Growth | Fast, sometimes low-quality | Slower, more loyal audience |
Editing style | Fast-paced, vertical, mobile-first | Detailed, structured, often horizontal |
📈 YouTube Shorts: Explosive Reach, Fast Follower Boost
Shorts are like TikToks — snackable, engaging, and algorithm-fueled.
Why they work:
-
YouTube is aggressively pushing Shorts
-
They get massive reach via the Shorts feed
-
New channels can gain 100s–1000s of subs from one viral short
⚠️ However:
-
Subscribers gained through Shorts may not watch long-form videos
-
Lower watch time + weaker loyalty = lower retention
-
Shorts alone rarely lead to sustainable growth
🧠 Long-Form Videos: Higher Engagement, Better Monetization
Long-form videos are still the backbone of YouTube.
Here’s why:
-
Higher watch time = better rankings
-
Better ad revenue potential
-
Viewers invest more = higher chance of subscribing + returning
-
More space for storytelling, education, trust-building
Cons?
-
Takes more effort to create
-
Takes longer to gain traction
-
Slower subscriber gain (initially)
🚀 Which One Drives More Growth?
It depends on what you mean by “growth.”
If you want:
✅ Faster visibility + subs → Shorts
✅ Watch time + monetization + trust → Long-form
But the smartest creators today use both strategically:
“Shorts for discovery. Long-form for depth.”
🔄 Hybrid Growth Strategy (Use Both)
Here’s a proven 3-part content system:
1. Use Shorts to Attract New Viewers
-
Post 2–4 Shorts per week
-
Use hooks in first 2 seconds
-
Add a CTA like “Full video in description”
2. Use Long-Form Videos to Retain Viewers
-
Post 1 high-value long-form video weekly
-
Solve specific problems
-
Add timestamps, storytelling, and strong CTAs
3. Cross-Promote Between Formats
-
Mention Shorts in long-form videos: “You might’ve seen my short on this…”
-
Embed Shorts in Community tab
-
Use Shorts to tease upcoming long-form content
📊 Analytics to Watch for Both
Metric | Shorts | Long-Form |
---|---|---|
Views per hour | ⬆️ High spike early | 📈 Steady over time |
Retention | ⬆️ 80–100% ideal | ⬆️ 50–60% ideal |
Subscribers | Many, low quality risk | Fewer, high loyalty |
Revenue | Minimal (Shorts Fund) | Scalable with ads |
🔑 Final Verdict
If you're just starting out:
-
Leverage Shorts for fast attention
-
Create long-form content for authority, trust, and monetization
The combination builds a growth engine:
📲 Shorts = impressions
📺 Long-form = conversions
At socialbulker.com, we help creators like you grow smart — not just fast. Content without a strategy is noise. Let’s help you go from viral clips to long-term brand.
Hand-Picked Articles
Carefully selected related content just for you

Best Editing Tips to Speed Up YouTube Video Production (Without Sacrificing Quality)
Want to upload more YouTube videos without burning out? Discover time-saving editing tips that help creators produce con...
Read Full Article
How to Script YouTube Videos That Keep Viewers Watching Until the End
Struggling with low audience retention on YouTube? Learn how to write video scripts that hook viewers from the start, ke...
Read Full Article