YouTube Shorts vs Long-Form Videos: Which One Drives More Growth?

Jun 29, 2025 SocialBulker

Not sure whether to focus on YouTube Shorts or long-form videos? Learn which format is better for growth, engagement, and monetization on YouTube.

image-alt-text

YouTube Shorts vs Long-Form Videos: Which One Drives More Growth?

If you’re serious about growing a YouTube channel in 2024 and beyond, you’ve likely asked yourself:

“Should I focus on Shorts or stick with long-form videos?”

The answer? Both can drive growth — but in very different ways.

In this post, we’ll break down:

  • The core differences between Shorts and long videos

  • Which drives faster subscriber growth

  • How each impacts your watch time, revenue, and visibility

  • And most importantly, how to use both formats strategically


🧠 The Key Differences: Shorts vs Long-Form Content

Feature YouTube Shorts Long-Form Videos
Length ≤ 60 seconds 8–15 minutes (typically)
Placement Shorts Feed + Search + Home Search + Suggested + Subscriptions
Discoverability Viral-oriented (wide audience) Targeted, SEO-driven
Monetization Lower RPM (ad rev is limited) Higher RPM (ads, mid-rolls, etc.)
Watch Time Doesn’t count toward 4,000-hour mark Counts toward monetization goal
Sub Growth Fast, sometimes low-quality Slower, more loyal audience
Editing style Fast-paced, vertical, mobile-first Detailed, structured, often horizontal

📈 YouTube Shorts: Explosive Reach, Fast Follower Boost

Shorts are like TikToks — snackable, engaging, and algorithm-fueled.

Why they work:

  • YouTube is aggressively pushing Shorts

  • They get massive reach via the Shorts feed

  • New channels can gain 100s–1000s of subs from one viral short

⚠️ However:

  • Subscribers gained through Shorts may not watch long-form videos

  • Lower watch time + weaker loyalty = lower retention

  • Shorts alone rarely lead to sustainable growth


🧠 Long-Form Videos: Higher Engagement, Better Monetization

Long-form videos are still the backbone of YouTube.

Here’s why:

  • Higher watch time = better rankings

  • Better ad revenue potential

  • Viewers invest more = higher chance of subscribing + returning

  • More space for storytelling, education, trust-building

Cons?

  • Takes more effort to create

  • Takes longer to gain traction

  • Slower subscriber gain (initially)


🚀 Which One Drives More Growth?

It depends on what you mean by “growth.”

If you want:

Faster visibility + subsShorts
Watch time + monetization + trustLong-form

But the smartest creators today use both strategically:

“Shorts for discovery. Long-form for depth.”


🔄 Hybrid Growth Strategy (Use Both)

Here’s a proven 3-part content system:

1. Use Shorts to Attract New Viewers

  • Post 2–4 Shorts per week

  • Use hooks in first 2 seconds

  • Add a CTA like “Full video in description”

2. Use Long-Form Videos to Retain Viewers

  • Post 1 high-value long-form video weekly

  • Solve specific problems

  • Add timestamps, storytelling, and strong CTAs

3. Cross-Promote Between Formats

  • Mention Shorts in long-form videos: “You might’ve seen my short on this…”

  • Embed Shorts in Community tab

  • Use Shorts to tease upcoming long-form content


📊 Analytics to Watch for Both

Metric Shorts Long-Form
Views per hour ⬆️ High spike early 📈 Steady over time
Retention ⬆️ 80–100% ideal ⬆️ 50–60% ideal
Subscribers Many, low quality risk Fewer, high loyalty
Revenue Minimal (Shorts Fund) Scalable with ads

🔑 Final Verdict

If you're just starting out:

  • Leverage Shorts for fast attention

  • Create long-form content for authority, trust, and monetization

The combination builds a growth engine:
📲 Shorts = impressions
📺 Long-form = conversions

At socialbulker.com, we help creators like you grow smart — not just fast. Content without a strategy is noise. Let’s help you go from viral clips to long-term brand.

SocialBulker

SocialBulker

Content Writer at SocialBulker

Hand-Picked Articles

Carefully selected related content just for you